I think chapter 5 is too much of a good thing for John. When he got a drink of water it turned to, clear, chocolate water. So it leaves John as thirsty as before he got the drink. When he gets back to his classroom, Miss Plimsole  waves her finger meaning ”You’re late.” He nibbles on his pencil and that of all things turned to chocolate. He told Miss Plimsole that his pencil turned to chocolate [ telling the truth ]  and she didn’t believe him because it’s like ”My dog ate my homework.” and even when John showed Miss Plimsole his pencil. In chapter 6 Ithink John is going to get a detention for making up a silly excuse. – Kylee gets a drink it’s ice-cold

Kyle